• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sheepshead Baygels: Fresh Bagels and Delectable Breakfast Sandwiches in Holmdel, NJ

At Sheepshead Baygels, nestled in Holmdel, NJ, tradition and taste collide to create an unforgettable bagel experience. Established in 1974, this charming deli pays homage to Brooklyn with its vintage memorabilia and a passionate dedication to crafting the perfect bagel. Their menu offers not only freshly baked bagels but also hearty breakfast options and specialty sandwiches, all served with a side of friendly service. Generous flavor combinations like the New Yorker sandwich and the classic egg, lox, and cream cheese bring nostalgia and satisfaction. With a cozy atmosphere and outdoor seating, Sheepshead Baygels invites you to savor a slice of New York in every bite.

Sheepshead Baygels at a glance

  • Address 2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733
  • Phone (732) 706-1266
  • Restaurant type Bagel shop .

Photos & Gallery

Sheepshead Baygels: Reviews & Ratings

David M. Dwight
4

January 25ih, 2026 Review Made it through the Weekend Shifts on Medic Unit #1201 and especially the Challenges of getting around during New Jerseys first significant snowfall in a number of years!!! Sue Lowe and I started the shift at one of our most reliable places for Breakfast... Sheepshead Bagels, 2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733... They have been there for everyone for nearly 30 years when they opened.. Sue enjoyed a very delicious Buttered Hard Roll... Since it was the second day working, I ordered Bacon, Egg, Cheese with sliced Tomatoes and Jalapenos seasoned with SPK on a Toasted Buttered Hard Roll!!! This place has always been there during harsh storms and produces a high quality sandwich!!! We were able to sit down inside a warm environment and enjoy our food without interruption... When getting ready to leave, paying my bill, I asked for one of their long Twisted Sesame Bagels for the journey home after the shift... Plan to share half of it with Kit Dwight for Breakfast when we make sandwiches!!! They have always made great food, from their regular offerings to special requests. This sandwich was on a hero roll, 2 fried eggs, jalapenos, salt, pepper, ketchup and a light touch of hot sauce. Finally got a sandwich for lunch this past Saturday and it was fabulous!!!

Matt Johns
5

Classic Pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel. Reduced one star for smaller bagel options, 10 styles or so. Baker's dozen for $18 is more than fair. Great quality, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Cash only and very limited coffee options. Bring your own travel mug, so hot you might get burned with their cup. Old School Jersey service, great experience.

Shubha Joshi
5

Their sfogliatella are a yummy weekend treat! Friendly staff and great service. Must try the make your own omelette with potatoes. Family run business with a very personal feel. I would buy here rather than the chains. This is my local go to breakfast place. However...its cash only. I wish they accepted credit card. I understand the fee is too much but maybe Dan Price can help?

Samantha Cummings
5

These are the best bagels outside of Brooklyn! The place has been in business since the '70s and when you try one of bagels you understand why. They have super fresh and really good homemade cream cheese as well as a selection of sandwiches and other goodies. The atmosphere is welcoming and patriotic, and the staff is very friendly and entertaining lol. We love coming here and highly recommend this establishment!

Sobhana
5

A very old timey looking place off the highway, but what a gem! The staff is kind and the parking lot just enough. It is CASH ONLY, but have an ATM inside. The registers are old, but that adds to the personality of the place. The owner was so kind and mindful of my religious restrictions that he washed the grill for me without my requesting it! I highly recommend stopping by for one of the fresh made bagels or a nice egg & cheese on a roll.

Kathy Coz
5

Great food and service!!! A lovely place with great history and even better food.

Kaitlyn Magaram
5

The best bagel in the area hands down. Has a nice crisp outside and soft inside, the BEC is a masterpiece. Everyone in the shop is super friendly and you feel like you’re part of a family. If you want a bagel that tastes like you got it in Brooklyn hands down this is the place.

L L
5

This was the most delicious bagel I've had in a very long time.. fresh and crispy. Cash only!!

Location

  • Sheepshead Baygels
    Sheepshead Baygels
    2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733 Hotline: (732) 706-1266

Welcome to the delightful world of Sheepshead Baygels, a cherished gem nestled in Holmdel, NJ, bringing a taste of authentic New York bagels right to the heart of Jersey. Established in 1974, this quaint eatery pays homage to its Brooklyn roots, featuring a charming decor adorned with memorabilia that transports you back to a classic deli experience.

At Sheepshead Baygels, the star of the show is undeniably the bagels. Customers rave about the freshness and texture—perfectly chewy with that iconic crunchy bottom. From traditional favorites to unique flavors, each bagel promises a delightful bite. Whether you're in the mood for a classic egg bagel topped with lox or a mini bagel that's as tasty as it is adorable, you’re in for a treat.

  • Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches: The menu shines with mouthwatering breakfast sandwiches that are sure to satisfy your morning cravings. Try the Holmdel Hornet, a delicious combination of pork roll, egg, cheese, potato, and a kick of hot sauce. Or, for a zestier option, opt for the Texas Breakfast Sandwich with roast beef and pepper jack.
  • Homemade Salads: The homemade tuna and chicken salads are another highlight, served in sandwiches or by the pound, providing a delectable, hearty meal.
  • Specialty Sandwiches: Not to be missed are the unique specialty sandwiches like the New Yorker and Soprano, stacked high with fresh ingredients and bold flavors, ensuring a satisfyingly savory experience.

The atmosphere at Sheepshead Baygels is inviting and family-friendly, with options for outdoor seating and ample space for groups. The friendly staff adds to the warm ambiance, making your visit feel personal and welcoming. Although it operates on a cash-only basis and might have occasional staffing shortages, it’s the dedication to quality that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Take it from satisfied customers like Glenn S. and Thomas P.—these bagels are worth the trip. With great reviews praising the friendly service and ample portions, it’s clear that Sheepshead Baygels is not just a restaurant; it’s a community staple where flavor and nostalgia come together in every bite. With the addition of on-site parking, Wi-Fi, and even a TV to catch up on your favorite shows, this spot is perfect for a laid-back brunch or lunch outing.

So next time you're in the Holmdel area, treat yourself to the delicious offerings at Sheepshead Baygels. Grab a bagel, indulge in a breakfast sandwich, and soak in the classic deli atmosphere that keeps this local treasure thriving. You won’t be disappointed!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • In-store pick-up for online orders
    • Offers takeaway